Twitter Icon

Quantumaniac is where it’s at - and by ‘it’ I mean awesome.

Over here I post a ton of physics / math / general interesting posts in an attempt to make your brain feel good. My aim is to be as informative as possible, all while posting fascinating things that hopefully enlighten us both a little to the mysteries of our truly wondrous universe(s?). Plus, how would you know if the blog exists or not unless you observe it? Boom, just pulled the Schrödinger’s cat card. Now you have to check it out - trust me, it said so in an equation somewhere.

Photobucket

Follow Quora

 

Supreme Court Rules Human Genes Cannot Be Patented

This morning, in a case challenging patents held by the Utah-based Myriad Genetics, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that human genes may not be patented.

Initially, the patents had been challenged by scientists and doctors who said that the patents hindered their ability to help patients.

The decision hewed closely to the position of the Obama administration, which had argued that isolated DNA could not be patented, but that complementary DNA, or cDNA, which is an artificial construct, could. The patentability of cDNA could limit some of the impact on industry from the decision.

The central question for the justices in the case, Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, No. 12-398, was whether isolated genes are “products of nature” that may not be patented or “human-made inventions” eligible for patent protection.

Myriad’s discovery of the precise location and sequence of the genes at issue, BRCA1 and BRCA2, did not qualify, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the court. “A naturally occurring DNA segment is a product of nature and not patent eligible merely because it has been isolated,” he said. “It is undisputed that Myriad did not create or alter any of the genetic information encoded in the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes.”

“Groundbreaking, innovative or even brilliant discovery does not by itself satisfy the criteria” for patent eligibility, he said.

But manipulating a gene to create something not found in nature, Justice Thomas added, is an invention eligible for patent protection. He also left the door open for other ways for companies to profit from their research.

They may patent the methods of isolating genes, he said. “But the processes used by Myriad to isolate DNA were well understood by geneticists, ” Justice Thomas wrote. He added that companies may also obtain patents on new applications of knowledge gained from genetic research.

Source: NY Times

  1. lefty-linda reblogged this from quantumaniac
  2. truetenor reblogged this from quantumaniac
  3. heycgcb reblogged this from ah-thenah
  4. ah-thenah reblogged this from contemplatingmadness
  5. niati reblogged this from sagansense
  6. chewtoy9696 reblogged this from quantumaniac
  7. smirnoffandstilettos reblogged this from sagansense
  8. ourbravenewworld reblogged this from sagansense
  9. sprocketdrox reblogged this from quantumaniac
  10. heavenbegatshell reblogged this from sagansense
  11. bartholomewfromthesun reblogged this from morgiecorgi and added:
    I’m a day late…but in addition to the ethical implications of this, it also has a big effect on academic research!
  12. eclectico-intermedio reblogged this from sagansense
  13. senjukannon reblogged this from the-nuclear-chaos
  14. the-nuclear-chaos reblogged this from quantumaniac
  15. thishumanz00 reblogged this from quantumaniac
  16. oliveyouidoxiii reblogged this from quantumaniac
  17. etre-exsangue reblogged this from quantumaniac
  18. sazzajayne reblogged this from xanthocomically
  19. asstronomyer reblogged this from quantumaniac
  20. wheresmypineapple reblogged this from sagansense
  21. satelliteyellow reblogged this from okorogariist and added:
    Man, the US has a really crappy patent law. They hadn’t decided this yet? it’s like IP 101 here. You cannot patent...
  22. drbutt reblogged this from monsterface
  23. awrrex reblogged this from quantumaniac and added:
    YESSS. SO GOOD. SCIENCE CAN PROGRESS. Now we just need to liberate Monsanto’s genetic patents to the public domain!
  24. the-uncarved-block reblogged this from augustrelativity and added:
    Holy shit, this is great news!
  25. augustrelativity reblogged this from quantumaniac and added:
    Good job, Justices. Doing the right thing.
  26. tooyoungforthissht reblogged this from drmufasa and added:
    Boom take that you greedy SOBs. UNANIMOUS.
  27. purg3 reblogged this from quantumaniac
  28. ninijen05 reblogged this from quantumaniac
  29. sparklefunshine reblogged this from sagansense
  30. joshzytkiewicz reblogged this from xanthocomically